Perhaps Carrie Underwood should forego the mascara while serving as a judge on American Idol. The new judge found has found herself reaching for the tissue box a time or two already this season and was once again moved during a contestant’s audition,

American Idol” contestant Samantha Ray paid tribute to her late sister with an audition that brought judge Carrie Underwood to tears during Sunday’s new episode.

JMarie might not be the first “American Idol” contestant to audition with a Carrie Underwood song — but she is the first to impress Underwood so much that the judge and Season 4 “Idol” winner forgot that “Before He Cheats” was her song.