Carrie Underwood shared a mysterious new video with fans, prompting some to question her appearance. The American Idol judge uploaded an Instagram video this week of herself outside, wearing large glasses and an all-white bejeweled suit.

Some fans didn’t recognize her, and there were lots of the plastic surgery allegations. Of course, a few rushed to her defense reminding everyone that Carrie had a serious facial injury in 2017, where she fell on her porch and had to get over 40 stitches. But that was 8 years ago…