Bryan, 48, said no and joked that he wanted to see if Underwood would "fight" for Windsor to advance to the next round. "My thing is, there's a Taylor Swift-esque quality that she

Underwood won Season 4 of the singing competition show in 2005, and recently returned for Season 23 as a judge.

Country singer Carrie Underwood took on a new role when she replaced Katy Perry as judge for the 23rd season of American Idol. It was the perfect fit as Carrie has plenty of experience with reality TV singing competition series — she won it once before.